Big Cartel was built specifically for independent artists, musicians, crafters, and makers who want to sell their work online without managing complex ecommerce software. The platform's design reflects this philosophy: clean, simple, uncomplicated. A ceramicist who makes 20 bowls per month, an illustrator selling prints, a musician selling merch — these are Big Cartel's ideal customers.
Shopify was built for businesses that sell products online and want to grow. The same platform that serves a 1-person Etsy-style business also serves a $100M DTC brand. That scalability comes with complexity — Shopify has hundreds of features, thousands of apps, and a learning curve that's steeper than Big Cartel's.
Big Cartel's setup process is the fastest in ecommerce. Upload a product, add a price, connect Stripe or PayPal, and you're selling. The admin is minimal — no overwhelming settings panels, no extensive configuration options. For a part-time creative business where setting up the store isn't the primary focus, Big Cartel's simplicity is genuinely valuable.
Shopify's admin is more complex. There are themes to configure, settings to navigate, shipping rules to set up, and optional apps to evaluate. The learning curve is manageable and Shopify's onboarding is good, but the complexity delta versus Big Cartel is real.
| Feature | Big Cartel Free | Big Cartel Gold ($15) | Shopify Basic ($39) |
|---|---|---|---|
| Products | 5 | 50 | Unlimited |
| Photo variants | 5 per product | 5 per product | Unlimited |
| Inventory tracking | Yes | Yes | Yes |
| Discount codes | No | Yes | Yes |
| Stats / analytics | Basic | Yes | Advanced |
| Custom domain | No | Yes | Yes |
| Shipping labels | No | Yes (ShipStation) | Yes |
| App integrations | Very limited | Very limited | 8,000+ |
| Transaction fee | 0% | 0% | 0% (Shopify Payments) |
| Sales channels (Amazon, Instagram) | No | No | Yes |
Big Cartel's limits are significant: 5 products free, 50 products max on the mid-tier plan (500 on the highest plan). For artists selling a rotating selection of limited-edition prints or handmade pieces, these limits may be fine. For a brand building a larger catalogue, they become constraints quickly.
| Plan | Big Cartel | Shopify |
|---|---|---|
| Free | Yes (5 products) | No |
| Entry paid | $15/month (50 products) | $39/month (Basic) |
| Mid-tier | $30/month (500 products) | $105/month |
| Transaction fee | 0% (all plans) | 0% (with Shopify Payments) |
Big Cartel is dramatically cheaper. The free plan is genuinely functional for artists with a handful of products. The $15/month plan is excellent value for small creative businesses. Shopify's $39/month entry price requires meaningful monthly sales to justify.
Sellable turns a single product photo into studio-quality images, UGC-style video ads, and on-brand campaigns — in under 60 seconds.
Try Sellable free →Big Cartel for: solo artists, musicians, crafters, and makers who sell a limited number of handmade or limited-edition items online, want a simple no-overhead platform, and don't need complex ecommerce features.
Shopify for: creative businesses that have grown beyond the hobby level, need to manage larger catalogues, want to sell on multiple channels (Amazon, Instagram, TikTok Shop), or plan to invest in paid advertising and email marketing.
The migration path is clear: start on Big Cartel, grow your creative business, migrate to Shopify when the product limits or feature needs exceed Big Cartel's capabilities.
Big Cartel has limited digital product support. You can sell digital downloads by linking to a Google Drive or Dropbox file, but there's no native digital delivery system. For serious digital product selling (courses, ebooks, music files), a dedicated platform like Gumroad or Sellfy is better. Shopify's digital product support is better via apps (SendOwl, Digital Downloads).
No. Big Cartel's free plan uses a yourstore.bigcartel.com subdomain. Custom domains are available on the $15/month Gold plan. Shopify includes custom domain connection on all paid plans.
No. Big Cartel charges zero transaction fees on all plans. You pay only the payment processor's fee (Stripe, PayPal, Square). Shopify also charges zero transaction fees when using Shopify Payments; the transaction fee only applies when using a third-party processor.
Big Cartel has limited social selling integrations. Direct TikTok Shop or Instagram Shopping integrations are not natively available. Shopify's social selling integrations (Instagram Shopping, TikTok Shop, Facebook Shops) are extensive. For brands using social media as a primary sales channel, Shopify's integrations are a significant advantage.
Big Cartel integrates with Printful (one of the leading print-on-demand services) allowing artists to sell custom-printed products without holding inventory. The Printful-Big Cartel integration works well for basic POD use cases. Shopify's print-on-demand integrations (Printful, Printify, Printmo, SPOD) are more extensive with more supplier options.
Ecommerce Platforms Inventory Software AI Photography Sign up for free and transform your product photography with Sellable.
Get started for free