Etsy has built the world's most concentrated audience of buyers specifically seeking handmade, vintage, and unique items. With 90M+ active buyers and a brand identity synonymous with "handmade," Etsy buyers are pre-qualified — they're specifically looking for the type of products artisan sellers make.
Amazon Handmade sits within Amazon's massive marketplace of 200M+ Prime members. The traffic opportunity is enormous, but the buyer intent is mixed — most Amazon shoppers are looking for commodity products at competitive prices. Handmade products compete for attention in a context where buyers are often searching for faster, cheaper alternatives.
The organic discoverability dynamics differ: Etsy's search algorithm rewards niche handmade products with relevant tags. Amazon Handmade's visibility comes from Amazon's standard search algorithm, which rewards conversion rate and reviews — advantages that established sellers have.
| Fee | Etsy | Amazon Handmade |
|---|---|---|
| Monthly subscription | Optional: $15/month (Etsy Plus) | Included in Professional ($39.99/month) |
| Listing fee | $0.20 per listing | None |
| Transaction fee | 6.5% | 15% (referral fee) |
| Payment processing | 3% + $0.25 | Included in referral fee |
| Shipping labels | Discounted (Etsy shipping) | Discounted (Buy Shipping) |
Etsy's fees for a $50 product: $0.20 listing + $3.25 transaction + $1.75 payment processing = $5.20 total (10.4% of sale price).
Amazon Handmade's fees for a $50 product: $7.50 referral fee (15%) with no additional payment processing fee. Total: $7.50 (15% of sale price).
Etsy is cheaper on a per-transaction basis for most handmade sellers. Amazon Handmade's higher referral fee is a significant margin consideration for lower-price-point products.
Etsy: Open to any seller. You can create an Etsy shop and list your first product within an hour. No application process. Sellers are responsible for complying with Etsy's handmade policy, but verification is minimal.
Amazon Handmade: Requires an application. Amazon verifies that you actually make the products you sell. You must describe your production process, provide photos of your workspace/process, and explain where you source materials. Approval can take 1–4 weeks and is not guaranteed.
For sellers who want to start immediately: Etsy. For sellers who have established production processes and want access to Amazon's audience: Amazon Handmade's verification is worth pursuing.
Etsy has become highly competitive. Popular categories (jewellery, candles, personalized gifts) have millions of listings. Standing out requires excellent photography, well-crafted tags and titles for Etsy SEO, competitive pricing, and strong review accumulation.
Sellable turns a single product photo into studio-quality images, UGC-style video ads, and on-brand campaigns — in under 60 seconds.
Try Sellable free →Amazon Handmade has lower listing density than Etsy in most categories — fewer handmade sellers compete for Amazon buyers' attention. However, Amazon Handmade products also compete against Amazon's standard marketplace for the same search terms, which includes mass-manufactured products that handmade items can't price-match.
Etsy for most handmade sellers starting out. The audience is pre-qualified for handmade purchases, the fee structure is lower, there's no application process, and Etsy's brand identity actively promotes artisan sellers. Start here.
Amazon Handmade as a second channel for established handmade sellers who have proven product-market fit on Etsy and want to access Amazon's Prime audience. The higher fee (15%) is a real cost consideration, but Amazon's traffic scale can more than compensate for sellers with strong conversion.
Both is the optimal long-term strategy — Etsy for its dedicated handmade audience, Amazon Handmade for Prime buyer access.
Yes. Many successful handmade sellers list on both platforms. Inventory management becomes important — ensuring you don't oversell when an item sells simultaneously on both platforms. At small volumes, managing this manually is feasible; at scale, a multichannel inventory tool is helpful.
Being on both platforms doesn't negatively affect either listing's performance. However, Amazon Handmade's product pages can potentially outrank your Etsy listings in Google Search for product-specific searches (Amazon generally has stronger domain authority than Etsy for generic searches). For brand searches, this is less of a concern.
Yes. Amazon Handmade has specific support for customized/personalized products. Buyers can submit personalisation details (names, dates, text) at checkout through Amazon's customization feature. This is comparable to Etsy's personalization options. Both platforms support custom order workflows for makers who produce to order.
If the new product type falls within your approved category (e.g., you applied as a jewellery maker and want to add a new jewellery line), no additional application is needed. If you want to sell in a new product category that wasn't covered in your original application (e.g., adding candles to your jewellery shop), you may need to submit additional information about your new production process.
On Etsy: natural light photography, lifestyle shots showing the product in use, and scale photos (showing the product next to a familiar object) consistently outperform white background-only listings. On Amazon Handmade: a clean white background main image is required by Amazon policy for the hero image, but lifestyle and detail shots in secondary images improve conversion significantly.
Ecommerce Platforms Inventory Software AI Photography Sign up for free and transform your product photography with Sellable.
Get started for free